If you've lived in Dexter more than a year, you already know fall doesn't arrive as one event. It shows up twice, a week apart, and the two Saturdays don't resemble each other at all. One puts you on a hay wagon rattling past a one-room schoolhouse while a fiddle band plays under a corncrib roof. The other puts you on Central Street watching someone's neighbor try to finish an apple pie in under two minutes while a parade of restored trucks idles nearby. Most people who've been here a while pick one and skip the other, assuming they're roughly the same thing wearing a different name. They aren't, and knowing the difference is the whole reason to clear both dates.
Webster Village comes first, and it's older than most people realize
The Webster Fall Festival hits its 43rd year on Saturday, September 26, out at Historic Webster Village on Webster Church Road. That's not a rounding-error anniversary. Four decades of the same festival, on the same land, run by the same two organizations, is the kind of continuity that doesn't survive by accident. The Webster Township Historical Society and Webster United Church of Christ co-host it, and the format has held steady because it isn't trying to be a downtown street fair. It's a working demonstration of what the township looked like before it was a township at all.
The music happens on the Dieterle Corncrib Stage, named for Richard Dieterle, who founded the RFD Boys, and the band still returns most years to play the same stage built in his memory. This year they share the bill with the Stout-Hearted String Band and Foxtree Folk Band, while a local dulcimer group sets up on the porch of the Scout Cabin for something quieter. Around them, the festival runs its usual craft demonstrations: blacksmithing, wool spinning, weaving, woodworking, the kind of skills that used to be Tuesday chores and are now things you watch a volunteer perform once a year.
The food side has its own reputation. Taste of Webster sells homemade pies, cookies, jams, local honey, and maple syrup out of the historic buildings, and two items in particular, the Bourbon Cherries and the Brandied Peach Jam, are made in small batches and tend to sell out before the day is half over. If you've been meaning to try them, arriving with the gates is not optional.
The festival also names a community honoree each year, someone whose service to Webster Township gets a formal thank-you in front of the crowd. This year that's Erik "Rick" Pedersen. It's a small tradition, but it says something about the event's character that a 43-year-old fall festival still stops to recognize one person by name rather than just running the schedule.
If you want a reason to linger past the food and music, the Dexter Area Historical Society is running a special program the next afternoon, Sunday, September 27, from 2 to 4 p.m., on Michigan's role in 20th-century toy manufacturing. It's a low-key add-on, but it's the kind of thing that only exists because a small historical society decided it was worth doing.
Apple Daze is the version most people picture when they hear "Dexter festival"
A week later, on Saturday, October 3, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., the scene shifts entirely to downtown. As The Sun Times News reports, Apple Daze takes over Monument Park, right across from Aubree's, and the Dexter Lions Club runs the whole thing the way it has for years. This is the version most people picture when they think "small-town fall festival": pumpkin bowling, putt-putt golf, bounce houses, craft booths, live music under the gazebo, and a lineup of classic cars parked along Central Street for the day.
The signature event is the apple pie eating contest, which draws a crowd every year less for the pie and more for the spectacle of watching someone commit to it in public. Families who want a quieter option can catch the KidSight trailer offering free vision screenings, or just walk the wagon hayride out to the Dexter Cider Mill for cider and donuts, which the Lions Club runs continuously through the day.
What makes Apple Daze different from Webster isn't the crowd size or the age of the tradition. It's the geography. Webster asks you to drive out to the township and step into something preserved. Apple Daze asks you to walk two blocks from wherever you already are. One is a destination. The other is an extension of a Saturday you were already having downtown.
The cider mill is the one thing both weekends share
Both festivals route people to the same place eventually: the Dexter Cider Mill on Central Street, which is marking its 140th season this year. As The Sun Times News reports, the mill was built in 1886 by William Van Natter, a Civil War veteran, and it has changed hands only twice since then. The Wagner family ran it through most of the 20th century and added the donuts in the 1950s. Richard Koziski bought it in 1986, and it's now run by Marty and Nancy Steinhauer, who've kept the wood press running on the same stretch of the Huron River the whole time.
That kind of continuity matters here for the same reason it matters at Webster Village. A cider mill hitting 140 years without changing ownership more than twice, or a festival hitting 43 years without changing hosts, tells you something about how Dexter treats its own traditions. It doesn't retire them. It runs them again, with small additions, the same way the mill added a hard cider tasting room and canned hard cider this season without touching the core menu of donuts and unpasteurized cider that's been the draw since before most of the town's current residents were born.
One practical thing worth knowing
The mill only takes cash or checks. No cards. If you're planning to swing by after either festival, especially on a weekend when the line runs long, bring bills. The mill is open Wednesday through Sunday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., through the fall season, and the parking lot fills fast enough that walking or biking in from downtown on a festival Saturday is often the faster option anyway.
Why both weekends are worth keeping
The easy mistake is treating these as interchangeable fall festivals and picking whichever one fits your schedule. They're not interchangeable. Webster Village is the township's memory: a demonstration of trades and a piece of land that's stayed almost untouched since the first settlers farmed it. Downtown's Apple Daze is the town's present tense: storefronts, a park across from a restaurant everyone already knows, a Lions Club that's been running the same event long enough that half the volunteers grew up attending it as kids.
Living in Dexter means having access to both versions of the place in the same two weeks. That's not a small thing. Plenty of towns this size have one identity. Dexter keeps two running side by side, one rural and preserved, one walkable and current, and the fall calendar is the clearest proof of it. Skip Webster and you miss the part of town that explains where everything else came from. Skip Apple Daze and you miss the part that's still being built.
If you're new enough to Dexter that this is the first year you're hearing about either one, September 26 and October 3 are both worth the calendar space. Bring cash for the mill either way.
Realty Experts works with buyers and sellers across Dexter and the rest of Washtenaw County, and part of that work is paying attention to the details that make a town worth living in beyond the listing sheet. If you're thinking about your next move here or anywhere in Southeast Michigan, Work With Brad.
